New York State is expanding a tax break that allows smaller companies to circumvent the $10,000 limit on state and local tax deductions from the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, similar to a workaround also being permitted in some other high-tax states.
The bill, which was passed by the legislature in April, enables "resident S corporations" to get larger tax benefits under the state's pass-through entity tax regime. Under the new rules, starting with tax year 2022, S corps in which all shareholders are New York State residents can now remit the pass-through entity tax on all income allocated to the resident shareholders on the shareholders' behalf, instead of limiting the PTET to only New York-sourced income. The legislation can also help S corporations in which the owners live in New York, but have significant projects going on in other states, according to a recent alert from the New York-based Top 100 Firm Anchin.
The legislature passed the bill about a month after the original date of March 15 for tax year 2022, so at first it seemed that only those businesses that had previously opted into the PTET were eligible to take advantage of the rule change because the budget bill didn't modify the PTET election due date. That would have affected many resident S corps with low New York income allocations that hadn't made the election by the deadline. However, New York then amended its PTET provisions to extend the election due date to Sept. 15, 2022, so S corps, partnerships and LLCs would have until mid-September to make the election.
The bill also includes a new, optional New York City Pass-Through Entity Tax for partnerships with at least one New York City resident partner, as well as city resident S corporations. It has been passed by both houses of the legislature. The tax will be imposed at the city's highest personal income tax rate of 3.876% and will contain an offsetting individual tax credit. For those businesses that opt in, an initial annual irrevocable election by March 15, 2023 will be required. The bill would make the NYC PTET retroactive to 2022, but Governor Kathy Hochul has not yet signed it.
The original PTET regime was effective starting in 2021, and the latest changes took effect in 2022.
In addition to New York, 13 other states had pass-through entity taxes prior to 2022, according to
They work in different ways. The Treasury Department is allowing them, although during the Trump administration it challenged a SALT cap workaround for individual taxpayers using the charitable deduction that former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo had tried to enact (
"It's really a workaround for the limitation on the state and local and real estate tax deductions on personal tax returns," said Phil Ross, an accounting and audit partner at Anchin who is practice leader of the firm's architecture, engineering and construction industry groups. "Right now, you're limited in what you can really deduct on your personal return for the amount of state and local income taxes that you pay. For pass-through entities, the entity itself is now in effect paying tax on behalf of the owners."
The company and the individual won't lose out on any money. "It's not as if the company paid $100,000 and New York State only gives you 90% credit for it," said Ross. "They're giving a dollar-for-dollar credit for it. In that instance, that $100,000 would reduce their K-1. It would reduce their federal K-1 income by that $100,000. They would have less tax to pay at the federal level and, in effect, get the benefit of those taxes as a tax deduction and not have this tax deduction limited at the personal level."
The tax provisions can vary from state to state, however. "Not every state has done it," said Ross. "Some other states actually don't give you the dollar-for-dollar credit. They give you 90% or 95% or some other percentage. New York State does give you 100%."
Those benefits could be important for taxpayers in these states as the Inflation Reduction Act that President Biden signed into law this week didn't include a rollback of the limitation of $10,000 on the SALT deduction for state and local income and sales taxes, as many Democrats had been hoping, especially in high-tax states like New York and New Jersey.
There are some other benefits too. "The state tax deduction on a personal return is also an addback for Alternative Minimum Tax purposes. Dollar for dollar, because this doesn't factor into the Alternative Minimum Tax calculation, it actually could be a little more beneficial than just removing the SALT limitation," said Ross.
More states are interested in passing such laws as a way to benefit residents, especially with tax revenues unexpectedly high this year in some states.
"Some states are different as to how it factors into allowing for a credit on your resident state for taxes paid, etc.," said Ross. "This regime is definitely helping the taxpayers in New York."
The legislative changes enhance the benefits this year for New York residents. "One of the changes now is for S corporation shareholders," Ross explained. "The company was really only going to be able to pay a tax on behalf of the shareholders that would reduce income and pass through as a credit to the shareholders to the extent of only allocated New York income, whether or not their shareholders were New York residents. This has changed now, where if you have all resident New York State, S corp shareholders, it doesn't matter if the company's allocation factor is very low for New York State. You can actually include all the income, pay a tax on all the income, reduce your taxable income and then get the full credit for it for New York State. That definitely was a nice change for New York State to benefit the residents."
California is also offering some SALT cap workarounds for businesses, but its requirements are more stringent than New York's and include limitations on overpayments to get refunds, according to Ross.
The Treasury and the IRS haven't been challenging such arrangements. "The IRS is sitting there saying, 'OK, if you're able to come up with a workaround, then we're not going to challenge it,'" said Ross.
There were some problems with the first year of the tax break in New York, but the process should be smoother this year. "The first year that they started it, it was a little bit of a cash flow issue because New York State required the individuals to make their state estimated tax payments without regard to the pass-through entity credits that they would get, so the company would be paying out estimated taxes and the individual would be paying out estimated taxes," said Ross. "Now in the second year, since it's already been around for a year and things are getting normalized, you don't have the potential for some of these duplicate payments or have to wait for refunds to come back or just apply it to the following year. In the second year, there is a benefit to that, and the cash flow is even better."
And the benefits should be even greater once the benefit is extended to local New York City taxes as well as state taxes in 2023. "New York City is coming out with their own pass-through entity tax, which is going to be for resident partners and for city residents, for the resident owners of the S corps as well," Ross added. "It's going to mimic it over there. It's just more welcome potential tax relief for New York City people and overall New York State people."
