Final IRS rules to IRA beneficiaries: Get going on those RMDs already

The IRS has quashed any remaining hope that it would alter its new guidelines for inherited individual retirement accounts, ending the "stretch" strategy for most beneficiaries.

With its finding in rules issued last month that tax revenue-raising provisions of the 2019 Secure Act require so-called noneligible beneficiaries who have inherited IRAs in 2020 or later to transfer all the assets into their income within a decade, the IRS told financial advisors and their clients that there would be no more delays in implementation or a shift in the final statutes. That means beneficiaries must begin taking required minimum distributions next year — if they haven't already started. But experts agree that it's likely past time to initiate that process.

"Everyone thought there was a mistake. The longer we waited for the final regulations, the more the industry seemed to be thinking, 'OK, they're actually going to hold us to this,'" Heather Zack, the director of high net worth solutions with Waltham, Massachusetts-based wealth management firm Commonwealth Financial Network, said in an interview.

READ MORE: IRA heirs, planners get additional RMD breathing room — again

That said, the rules point to "a strategy that most advisors were taking already" in seeking to "equalize distributions over 10 years" rather than setting up a "tax bomb" by taking them all at once, she noted. "I don't think there were many advisors who were telling their clients, 'Let's wait and take out everything in year 10.'"

The rules' implications to retirement planning with "a tax component" merit a conversation with clients who inherited an IRA in any of the past four years, said Matthew Cleary, a financial planner with Wakefield, Massachusetts-based 401(k) and wealth firm Sentinel Group.

"We want to bring that up absolutely, because it may be a situation where you do want to have more of a schedule to minimize the tax burden of taking it out in one year," Cleary said in an interview. "There are a couple of exceptions to that rule, but for the most part the stretch IRA is dead."

Caveats to the new 10-year requirement apply to eligible designated beneficiaries — a group that includes the spouse of the deceased IRA owner, heirs who are chronically ill or disabled, and heirs younger than the late retirement saver by only a decade or less, Zack and Cleary noted. Another carve-out from the mandatory distributions applies to heirs who are 20 years old or younger, who can still use the stretch strategy until they are 21, according to a blog post by Sarah Brenner, director of retirement planning for IRA advice firm Ed Slott & Company. At that age, the new rules state that the beneficiary must launch their distributions and empty the accounts into their own income within the 10-year window.

READ MORE: New tax law obliterates IRA trust planning

In addition, the rules maintained the "controversial" provision that most beneficiaries are subject to the 10-year guideline — even if the account owner died on or after the beginning period for the holder's own required minimum distributions, Brenner wrote in another blog.

"This rule requires annual RMDs to continue once they have started," she wrote. "Many believed this rule went away with the Secure Act, but apparently the IRS thought differently. Due to all the confusion its interpretation caused, the IRS waived RMDs during the 10-year period for beneficiaries for the years 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024. In the newly released final regulations, the IRS is doubling down on its position that these annual RMDs are required. They must be taken starting in 2025. However, the IRS will not impose penalties for annual RMDs that were not taken for years before 2025."

In its announcement, the IRS specifically discussed the concerns around that interpretation.

"Treasury and IRS reviewed comments suggesting that a beneficiary of an individual who has started required annual distributions should not be required to continue those annual distributions if the remaining account balance is fully distributed within 10 years of the individual's death as required by the Secure Act," the agency said in its July 18 press release. "However, Treasury and IRS determined that the final regulations should retain the provision in the proposed regulations requiring such a beneficiary to continue receiving annual payments."

As part of his characteristically detailed social thread examining the tax impact of a newly released rule, Buckingham Strategic Wealth Chief Planning Officer and Kitces.com blog Lead Financial Planning Nerd Jeffrey Levine reported that finding as the answer to "the No. 1 question advisors have asked for 2+ years now," adding, "Sorry, I don't make the rules, I just report them!!!" The industry had been eagerly anticipating the guidelines, he said.

"I honestly can't remember a time when advisors, tax pros and 'mom and pop' investors more eagerly awaited news from the IRS," Levine said. "But more than 4.5 years after Secure was passed, we now have some definitive answers to key Q's."

READ MORE: IRS gives IRA heirs a break and more flexibility for financial advisors

IRA owners seeking to avoid a tax hit on their beneficiaries could convert traditional accounts to Roth ones, which usually won't carry any more duties tied to the added income, Cleary noted.

"They would still be subject to the 10-year rule, but then they don't necessarily have the tax issue," he said. "It's an idea for the right person who's able to pay those taxes up front."

While there are "not a ton" of strategies that advisors can take to reduce the impact of the distributions on their income once they start taking them, separate charitable donations and maximizing other deductions could mitigate part of the burden, Zack said. 

Since inherited IRAs are "something that every advisor deals with," the rules have created "this whole maze of different beneficiary withdrawal requirements" based on the year of the account owner's death and the age, spousal and health status of the heir, she noted. And the final rule clarified that the 10-year distribution span started with IRA owners who died in 2020 — regardless of the fact that the IRS pushed back the required distribution four years in a row.

"It's just made the landscape a lot more complicated for advisors and clients now than it used to be," Zack said. "That is definitely of concern for some folks. That clock has been running this entire time."