White House officials said the administration has no plans to do away with the payroll tax despite President Donald Trump saying he would seek a permanent repeal if he wins another term.
Even if Trump were to follow through, the idea of doing away with the tax is unlikely to get much support in Congress because it could drive up the deficit by trillions of dollars to plug a funding gap, or spell the end of some Social Security payments for millions of Americans.
“The idea is drastic and crazy,” said Brian Riedl, a senior fellow at the conservative Manhattan Institute. “It is complete fantasyland.”
Alan Viard, resident scholar at the conservative American Enterprise Institute and a former Treasury official in the George W. Bush administration called it “absolutely insane” and an “unfathomable” proposal.
“The only silver lining here is that there is zero chance of this being adopted,” Viard said.
Radical revamp
Trump has suggested a radical revamp to the taxes, which fund Social Security and Medicare, several times over the past week, saying he’ll make a move in that direction if he wins re-election.
“On the assumption I win, we are going to be terminating the payroll tax after the beginning of the new year,” Trump said Wednesday.
White House press secretary Kayleigh McEnany and a second official, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said Trump is only talking about forgiving the worker payroll taxes he deferred last week with an executive action set to be in place from Sept. 1 to the end of the year.
“What he was meaning yesterday is he wants permanent forgiveness of the deferral,” McEnany said at a press briefing Thursday.
‘Terminate the tax’
But Trump has said more than once he wants to end the payroll tax. “If I win, I may extend and terminate. In other words, I’ll extend it beyond the end of the year and terminate the tax,” he said of the payroll tax on Aug. 8.
Congress would need to act to terminate the 6.2 percent payroll tax that funds Social Security or the 1.45 percent levy that funds Medicare. Democrats are universally opposed to any cuts in the payroll taxes that would harm these benefits.
While Republicans are more open to policies that would reduce the program’s costs over time, Congressional leaders have been wary of even a short-term reduction in payroll taxes because programs are already in danger of becoming insolvent.
If Congress terminated those levies at the end of this year, the trust funds would have enough money to pay retirement benefits for two and a half years, disability benefits for eight months, and Medicare payments for six months, according to Riedl’s estimates.
Deficit spending
Congress would likely then step in to fund those programs with general revenues, which would amount to adding $16 trillion to the deficit over a decade, rather than let those benefits expire, he said.
Even Trump’s short-term plan has deficit implications. On Tuesday, White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow said the administration would “bond out” — that is, borrow money — to cover any Social Security or Medicare shortfalls that may arise.
Asked on Wednesday about how he intended to pay for Social Security from the general fund, Trump said “we’re going to have tremendous growth,” suggesting other tax revenues would rise.
“His pledge to replace lost revenue with growth is a classic Trump con,” Senator Ron Wyden, the top Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, said in a statement. “Republican tax cuts have never delivered promised growth.”
Changes to Social Security, a program with widespread support that’s been around since 1935, were once called the “third rail” of American politics — an allusion to the danger of electrocution.
The program created during the Great Depression is the largest single source of income for older Americans, providing the majority of income for half of retirees, and at least 90 percent of income for 18 percent of retirees, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a progressive think-tank.
Social Security and Medicare already face a dire outlook with retirement funds projected to run out by 2035,
Trump on Aug. 8 announced an executive action to
— With assistance from Justin Sink
